Aluminum vs. Wrought Iron Fences: Which Is Best for North Shore Homes?

The Appeal of Ornamental Fencing in the North Shore

Many North Shore neighborhoods feature beautiful homes with classic architecture, landscaped yards, and curb appeal that stands out. Fences here aren’t just about marking property lines—they’re often chosen for aesthetic value and security.

Both aluminum and wrought iron fencing deliver a high-end look that complements upscale homes, historic neighborhoods, and modern designs. These fences are especially popular for:

• Front yard enclosures that add prestige and style.

• Backyard borders where beauty matters as much as function.

• Pool fencing (aluminum, in particular, for code compliance).

• Driveway gates for added security and presence.

Aluminum Fencing: Modern Strength with Minimal Upkeep

Aluminum fencing has become a go-to option for many North Shore homeowners. Here’s why:

Key Benefits of Aluminum Fences

1. Lightweight but Strong
   Aluminum may weigh less than iron, but it’s engineered to be durable. Powder-coated finishes protect against rust, making it ideal for Illinois weather.

2. Rust & Corrosion Resistance
   Unlike wrought iron, aluminum won’t rust. This makes it perfect for humid summers, snowy winters, and rainy springs common in North Shore and Chicagoland.

3. Low Maintenance
   Aluminum fences rarely need more than occasional rinsing with a hose. No sanding, repainting, or sealing required.

4. Cost-Effective
   Aluminum fences tend to cost less upfront than wrought iron, especially for large properties.

5. Versatility in Style
   Available in a variety of heights, colors (black, bronze, white, green), and designs, aluminum can mimic the look of wrought iron without the upkeep.

6. Pool-Friendly
   Meets most Illinois pool safety codes, making it the preferred choice around swimming pools.

Potential Downsides of Aluminum

• Not as heavy or “solid” as wrought iron, which can matter for homeowners wanting maximum security.

• Can dent under strong impact (though not easily).

Wrought Iron Fencing: Traditional Elegance & Timeless Strength

For decades, wrought iron has been the gold standard of luxury fencing in upscale neighborhoods like Wilmette, Northbrook, and Glenview.

Key Benefits of Wrought Iron Fences

1. Classic Elegance
   Wrought iron is unmatched in prestige. Its ornate scrolls, spear tops, and heavy construction elevate the curb appeal of historic and luxury homes.

2. Unparalleled Strength
   Thick, heavy, and nearly impossible to bend or break, wrought iron is one of the strongest fencing materials available.

3. Customizable Designs
   Wrought iron is often hand-forged, allowing intricate patterns, decorative flourishes, and unique artistry.

4. Longevity
   With proper care, wrought iron fences can last 50+ years. Many historic homes in Chicagoland still have original iron fences standing tall.

Potential Downsides of Wrought Iron

• High Maintenance: Iron must be sanded and repainted regularly to prevent rust.

• Higher Cost: Wrought iron fencing is usually more expensive than aluminum.

• Susceptible to Rust: Especially in the Midwest climate where snow, salt, and moisture are constant.

• Heavier Installation: Installation costs may be higher due to weight and complexity.

Aluminum vs. Wrought Iron: Head-to-Head Comparison

Which Fence Fits North Shore Homes Best?

The “best” choice depends on your property goals and lifestyle.

• Choose Aluminum if:

  • You want a stylish, low-maintenance fence.

  • You live in a climate-sensitive area near water or with frequent snow (like Skokie or Schaumburg).

  • You’re enclosing a pool or want an affordable alternative to wrought iron.

• Choose Wrought Iron if:

  • Your home is historic or high-end, and appearance is the top priority.

  • You’re willing to invest in upkeep to maintain the fence’s integrity.

  • You want the absolute strongest and most imposing option for security.

Local Considerations for North Shore Homeowners

In North Shore suburbs, it’s not just about personal preference—there are also local codes, HOAs, and climate realities to think about:

• Municipal codes: Some towns restrict fence height or require specific pool fencing. Aluminum usually meets these requirements more easily.

• HOA rules: Neighborhood associations in upscale areas like Northbrook and Wilmette may require ornamental styles that aluminum can replicate.

• Weather challenges: Winters in Illinois are tough on wrought iron. If you don’t want to budget for repainting every few years, aluminum may be a better long-term fit.

• Historic homes: In areas with vintage properties, wrought iron may be more historically appropriate and preserve authenticity.

Why Work with Atlantic Fence Inc

At Atlantic Fence Inc, we’ve helped countless homeowners in Northbrook, Glenview, Wilmette, Skokie, Arlington Heights, Palatine, Schaumburg, and other Chicagoland communities choose the right fence for their needs. We provide:

• Custom aluminum and wrought iron installations designed to match your home’s architecture.

• Professional guidance on codes, permits, and HOA requirements.

• Durable materials built to withstand Midwest weather.

• Transparent pricing so you know your investment is fair.

Conclusion

Both aluminum and wrought iron fences bring beauty, security, and lasting value to North Shore homes. Aluminum offers a modern, low-maintenance solution perfect for the local climate, while wrought iron delivers timeless elegance and maximum strength for those willing to maintain it.

If you’re considering a new fence in North Shore, IL or the surrounding suburbs, contact Atlantic Fence Inc today for a free consultation. We’ll help you compare options, navigate local codes, and design a fence that fits your home, lifestyle, and budget.